One of the most challenging aspects in structuring an M&A transaction is not necessarily the determination of a purchase price, but rather how that purchase price is allocated between the assets being sold. The major conflict at the core of this issue is the existence of tax polarity between the buyer and the seller. Generally speaking, the seller of the business is trying to maximize after tax proceeds while the buyer is trying to minimize the consideration relative to the after tax cash flow of future operations. Given these concerns, sellers typically look to sell stock while buyers usually want to buy assets. (Many times buyers prefer asset purchases because, in most jurisdictions, it limits liability. In Brazil, for example, it does not limit liability.)
Section 1060 of the IRS tax code attempts to mitigate conflicts regarding the allocation of the purchase price to various assets. Under Section 1060, both the buyer and the seller of a business are required to use the residual method for purchase price allocation. This means that the purchase price is first allocated to assets to the extent of their fair market value and any excess will be allocated to goodwill and going concern value.
A purchase price allocation is important to include in a purchase contract between a buyer and a seller because it gives guidance as to the tax consequences of the transaction. An allocation acknowledged by the two parties will allow the buyer to determine the basis of depreciable and amortizable assets while the seller is able to compute the sales price of the individual assets in order to determine any recapture amounts. With an allocation in place, the seller is also able to determine capital gains and ordinary income from an asset sale.
Although coming to an agreement about purchase price allocation can be challenging, having a tax expert and an experienced investment bank negotiating between buyer and seller will help both parties reach agreement on an allocation that is beneficial or at least fair to both parties and that conforms to IRS standards.
