<img src="http://www.sas15k01.com/49531.png" style="display:none;">
Oct 30

The Value of Earnouts – Earnouts defined

Donald Grava October 30, 2014

Many times, in middle market transactions, buyer and seller do not agree on the purchase price. One way to bridge the valuation gap between buyer and seller is to structure an earn-out. An earn-out is a payment plan in which the buyer will make additional payments to the seller based upon the performance of the newly acquired business. Earn-outs can be essential to closing M&A transactions in which the buyer and seller cannot agree on the value. Earn-outs are designed to ensure that each party receives fair value as a result of the transaction.

Gears

There are several advantages to structuring an earn-out. Earn-outs can reduce negotiation time in cases where neither buyer nor seller can agree on a valuation. An earn-out can help the selling party receive the full value for their business by the seller making specific payments, over time, based on the seller achieving specific performance criteria. Through the use of an earn-out, the selling company may receive more money (or shares) than they would have if the acquisition were a one-time payment at closing. Buyers like the use of earn-outs because it reduces the risk of overpaying for an investment that does not achieve its financial projections. Because of this risk mitigation for both buyer and seller, earn-outs are oftentimes used as a way to make a fair compromise on the purchase price of the target company.

Experienced M&A advisers can help structure and negotiate an earn-out that will be acceptable to both buyer and seller. A well-structured earn-out can be beneficial to all parties involved. The buyer feels confident they are not overpaying for the company because the seller has to achieve certain performance thresholds in order to receive additional payments. The seller is satisfied because additional consideration will be paid if the business does achieve its forecasts. The earn-out has the added benefit of demonstrating to the buyer that the seller believes in the forecasts and that the seller is not in a hurry to exit the business. (Most of the time, the founder or seller of a company stays with the company during the earn-out period to help insure that the company will achieve the desired results.)

Oct 24

The Challenge of Purchase Price Allocation

Donald Grava October 24, 2014

 

 

IRS Image

One of the most challenging aspects in structuring an M&A transaction is not necessarily the determination of a purchase price, but rather how that purchase price is allocated between the assets being sold. The major conflict at the core of this issue is the existence of tax polarity between the buyer and the seller. Generally speaking, the seller of the business is trying to maximize after tax proceeds while the buyer is trying to minimize the consideration relative to the after tax cash flow of future operations. Given these concerns, sellers typically look to sell stock while buyers usually want to buy assets. (Many times buyers prefer asset purchases because, in most jurisdictions, it limits liability. In Brazil, for example, it does not limit liability.)

Section 1060 of the IRS tax code attempts to mitigate conflicts regarding the allocation of the purchase price to various assets. Under Section 1060, both the buyer and the seller of a business are required to use the residual method for purchase price allocation. This means that the purchase price is first allocated to assets to the extent of their fair market value and any excess will be allocated to goodwill and going concern value.

A purchase price allocation is important to include in a purchase contract between a buyer and a seller because it gives guidance as to the tax consequences of the transaction. An allocation acknowledged by the two parties will allow the buyer to determine the basis of depreciable and amortizable assets while the seller is able to compute the sales price of the individual assets in order to determine any recapture amounts. With an allocation in place, the seller is also able to determine capital gains and ordinary income from an asset sale.

Although coming to an agreement about purchase price allocation can be challenging, having a tax expert and an experienced investment bank negotiating between buyer and seller will help both parties reach agreement on an allocation that is beneficial or at least fair to both parties and that conforms to IRS standards.

Oct 16

Valuation Approaches for M&A

Donald Grava October 16, 2014

graphics-money-symbols

When determining the value of a business, there are three basic approaches that can be used to determine the fair market value. These three approaches are the underlying asset approach, the market comparable approach, and the income approach.

The underlying asset approach is a technique in which the assets of the business determine how much it is worth. The assets being valued are both tangible and intangible which means they are considered in the valuation regardless of whether or not they show up on the balance sheet. The final value of the business is determined by a simple formula: Assets – Liabilities = Value of the Business.

Another common method of valuing a firm is the market comparable approach. This is where one compares a business to publicly held firms whose stock is trading. A value is derived by examining the public firm’s EV/EBITDA or EV/Revenue multiples and applying a similar multiple to the non-public, target firm. (EV = Enterprise Value and EBITDA = Earnings Before Interest Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization)

The third way of valuing a company is the income approach. The income approach is based on the company’s potential earnings in the future. The most common way of doing this is by using the discounted cash flow method. The discounted cash flow method (DCF) is where one projects the cash flows that the business will generate and then discount these returns to their present value.

No matter which approach is used, the accuracy of the valuation will depend on the level of detail and depth of analysis that is used in deriving that valuation. It is important to ensure the accuracy of all inputs used in these valuation approaches as these inputs will ultimately impact the value calculation of the target company.

One final note on valuations; “paper” valuations are interesting and useful, but they may or may not be an indication of what a willing buyer may pay a willing seller. Versailles Group has sold a number of businesses for more than any “paper” valuation would have indicated. The key to achieving such a valuation is to have the right buyers and a strong auction.

Oct 09

eBook - When to Sell Your Business

Donald Grava October 9, 2014
ebook2-pdf-150

 

 

Versailles Group is pleased to announce the publication of its first eBook, "When To Sell Your Business."

Most entrepreneurs spend more time building their businesses than planning for eventual sale. This guide is meant to assist entrepreneurs in deciding the timing for the sale of their business.

To download your copy, please follow the link at the top of the page.

Oct 08

Q3 2014 M&A Update

Donald Grava October 8, 2014

M&A deal activity is continuing at a rapid pace. Global volume this year has already exceeded US$3 trillion and will likely surpass last year’s record volume.

One particularly bright spot for M&A activity has been Europe. For the first time in recent history, European M&A has expanded dramatically. For the first three quarters of 2014, this has meant nearly US$800 billion of transaction volume. By comparison, for the same time period last year, there was less than US$500 billion of transaction volume in Europe.

 

Second September Email Blast Pic

Oct 02

What is Due Diligence?

Donald Grava October 2, 2014

What is Due Diligence?

A question sellers often have is what is due diligence? Due diligence is the process that takes place after a letter of intent (LOI) is signed, but before the closing of the deal. It is a detailed investigation into the potential investment in order to verify the assets and liabilities and to make sure that the buyer understands what it is acquiring. Normally, it entails a complete review of the business, products, customers, facilities, background checks on the management, technological reviews, etc.

blog photo

If the due diligence process is not comprehensive, then the buyer runs the risk of serious financial losses. It is imperative for the buyer to understand how the business operates and the potential risks before closing the deal no matter how big or small that acquisition may be. Due diligence is a way to ensure that neither party involved in the transaction was misled so the deal can be closed successfully.

Three major areas of financial due diligence
Most often the three most important areas of the financial diligence are; (i) the quality and accuracy of the financial statements and related information, (ii) the sustainability of the cash flows, and (iii) a thorough understanding of the tax issues that may arise due to a possible change of ownership. Prior to a sale, owners can significantly improve the value of their business by focusing on these three areas to make sure there are no issues.

Most buyers prefer audited financial statements; however, in the middle-market, a majority of the companies do not have audited statements, primarily due to the high cost. If a seller does not have audited financial statements, the most important thing is to have accurate financial data that is prepared in accordance with GAAP. Sloppy or inaccurate accounting data always makes buyers nervous about the value of the assets and the possibility that liabilities are under-reported.

The sustainability of the seller’s cash flows is very important to potential buyers as this information provides excellent visibility into the possible future performance of the target company. Buyers also like to know which products and services generate the highest margins and have the greatest growth potential in order to better recognize how they can integrate these products and services into their strategic plans and current product offerings. Buyers tend to pay higher multiples when there is a strong, diversified customer base from which they can grow the company.

It’s important that a seller understand that if the diligence doesn’t go well, the buyer may elect not to close the transaction or may ask for a price reduction. For that reason, sellers should make sure that their accounting records are up to date and accurate. Furthermore, to the extent possible, sellers should think about the most important parts of their business and make sure that they are ready to withstand the scrutiny of someone else’s due diligence.